dreadedcandiru2 (dreadedcandiru2) wrote,
dreadedcandiru2
dreadedcandiru2

On privilege blindness, model trains and town halls.

As you might have figured out from my annoying comments about how Mike interprets everything Elly does as a means of punishing him for being alive, it's pretty clear to me that behind his angry comments about how she's supposed to lead her life without going anywhere because it's rotten of her to embarrass him in front of his friends is the short-sighted and stupid belief that she's only doing so because she's decided that his wanting to go through the day without being picked on is a bad thing that he must be punished for. This stupid belief is why he thinks that Elly decided to sing in public with the sole intent of making life worse for some child to be named later and why he thinks that April fooled all of them so that Elly could punish him for wanting the street cred he's bad for wanting to have.

What we tend to lose sight of when we focus on Mike being a vain half-wit who makes everything into a referendum about his public image is that John was not at all interested in Elly's crusade to save the town hall. This seems to be part of a wider pattern in which he makes a point of being totally disinterested in anything that makes her feel like more than a nobody doomed to go down in history as nothing more than that useless figure who might as well not have lived at all: someone's wife or someone's mother. When you listen to his whining about how her having a career destroys his home and how remodeling the kitchen just because she wanted a change is a needless expense because his mother never complained about clapped-out appliances, you end up realizing that his idea of give and take is that he takes without giving and she gives without taking.

This belief is reinforced by the fact he regards her as a poor sport for not caring about HIS stupid interests. She doesn't like model trains because she doesn't know how to have fun. She doesn't like sports cars because she wants to make him into an old fogey. She doesn't like this, that or the other thing because she doesn't seem to want to agree with something everyone knows: men get to do interesting stuff while women are fated to tend house and shut up about it. This not-needing-to-be-spoken belief of his means that the the television adaptation in which he makes an oafish comment about Elly getting back to her real job of being a housewife means that his response would be a variation on the phrase but that's different should the dichotomy be pointed out to him.

The reason for his smug belief that he's not supposed to care about outside interests that should probably be discouraged so as to preserve his home is that John has privilege blindness. Since John clearly believes that Elly's complaints about how the system is rigged against her are so much rubbish because the system works in his favor, it would take a Herculean mental effort on his behalf to see that maybe it isn't crazy woman hormones that make her want something she "shouldn't" want because she "doesn't" need it; since he's a very lazy man who doesn't like to upset apple carts any more than he likes the idea of being the bad guy, we're going to have to wait until they slam the crematorium door on him for her to be rid of his stupidity and short-sightedness.
Tags: john patterson: confused philosopher
Subscribe

  • On real work and how to discourage it.

    The irritating thing about the first time that each child is sent to Exile Farm that is not Elly getting her bowels in an uproar about a child having…

  • Breaking the gossip machine

    Of course, the presence of Molly and Gayle in the Thomas household when their dad was being a spineless git with no will of his own is not the only…

  • John, Fiona and the Great Big Own-Goal.

    One of the more irritating things about the current arc is Lynn's choice to make Elly more readily sympathetic by making her look like someone with…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 0 comments